gymn
Digest
Wed, 3 Aug 94 Volume 2 :
Issue 160
Today's Topics:
Bobrava
Don't Forget!!!!
GG, M Team
GG,
names, newspaper typos
Goodwill Games (Rhythmic)
Goodwill RSG EF Results
GWG,Men's team
Indian Gymnastics (was Re: names)
Kochetcova discredited unfairly
Marianna Webster
Men's team
Men's Team & RSG Rundown as Well as AA Predictions
names (7 msgs)
NY Times on eating disorders
PR, USA Nationals
Retton's 10th anniversary
RSG Results from Goodwill
Senior Men - National Qualifyer scores (2 msgs)
Shannon
Wants
to go Back
(3 msgs)
Women's AA Comments
This is a digest of the gymn@athena.mit.edu
mailing list.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 22:02:43 -0400 (EDT)
From: <***@gateway.us.sidwell.edu>
Subject:
Quick break from watching for a commentator bash. If you thought they
were bad before ;).
Actually, you just have to look at the entire thing
in light of the social implications. It's obvious that Kathy cannot take
her eyes off of Bart, and that's why she seems to miss
everything but
everyone's toes. (example:
opening - she agreed with everything he said,
but
didn't look at the camera at all.
Instead, he was the focus of
attention
(from ehr)).
Anyhow..
How it related to the
gymnastics. I think that (so far of
what I've seen)
there have been a lot of calls by
our beloved commentators in advance of
the action
(mostly incorrectly?). I think it
was bart who went "and
a
solid landing" or something before (I don't
recall who) made a mess of the
landing. Well, you win some you lose some.
I'll leave my comments
concerning the gymnastics itself until after it's
over.
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 14:32:40 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Bobrava
What ever happened to Natalia Bobrava? Did
she retire? Did she fall
behind
when the Russian team really started to
progress?---Brian
------------------------------
Date: Tue, 2
Aug 1994 13:58:25 -0400
From: ***@yfn.ysu.edu
Subject: Don't
Forget!!!!
>
>Goodwill Games Gymnastics are on *every* day
starting Saturday. On Tuesday
>there is RSG. Sat-Mon. is the women's comp. Tues-Fri. the
men take the stage.
>Susan
>
>
Will RSG be on
TBS? I didn't see it in the posted
schedule.
>
------------------------------
Date: Tue,
2 Aug 1994 19:24:37 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
GG, M Team
Scores from Reuters:
Men's team:
1. Russia (Dmitry Vasilenko,
Alexei Volopayev,
Yevgeny
Shabayev, Alexei Nemov)
171.200
2.
Belarus (Ivan Pavlovsky, Andrei Kan,
Vitaly
Rudnitsky,
Alexander Shostak)
167.875
3. U.S.(Drew Durbin, Blaine Wilson,
Chainey
Umphrey, Scott Keswick)
165.525
4.
Romania (Dan Burinca, Sandro
Nistor, Robert
Taciulet,
Cristian Leric)
164.950
5. China
(Dun Van, Chjon Dun, Chunsin
Yuan,
Lyan Chjen)
163.950
6. Italy (Fabio Fedozzi,
Giovanni D'Innocenzio,
Gianmetteo
Centazzo, Paolo Bucci)
163.600
7. Japan
(Honda Morimasa, Makoto Tamura,
Akihiro Hiramatsu, Takashi Chinen)
160.550
Notes from Reuters:
-The Russian men
won "with almost embarrassing ease."
-Like the Russian
women's squad, three of the four athletes were in
the
top 12 this year at Worlds.
-The top individual was UKR's Misutin, who was competing as an
individual
(ie his team wasn't there).
-Keswick fell off Pbars and Hbar, and then
performed poorly on Pommels
(8.80).
However, he scored a 9.775 on the "rungs".
-Voropaev scored the highest mark of the night, a 9.8, on
rings.
However, he also fell on high bar and scored only 8.85 on the
horse.
He was 3rd at this year's worlds...
Notes from UPI...
-Shabayev was the top Russian performer. He was 5th at this
year's
Worlds. He had 56.925
points.
-Nemov scored 9.75 on pbars and 9.70 on floor.
Nemov:
"I was very happy with my performance today, although I
suffered in the vault because I tried something
new."
-The Russian team had a two-tenths deduction because Voropaev wore
white shorts on
floor. The UPI says
"the official Russian strip is
all-blue."
-- so I'm not sure if the shorts are white with a blue
stripe
or maybe all-blue?
-Misutin scored
57.100.
Art Shurlock [head coach, US]:
"Russia are definitely extremely strong
-- much
stronger than they were at the World University Games (in New
York in
1993)."
Rachele
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 3 Aug 94 9:52:53 EDT
From: <***@BBN.COM>
Subject: GG, names,
newspaper typos
If Reuters thought Scott Keswick did well on the
"rungs,"
the NY Times was even more
confused about Shannon Miller
during the
all-around. Monday's paper had a
picture of
her blocking off the horse during one
of her vaults,
and the caption described her as
"hitting the bar during
her
vaults."
This may have been mentioned before in the discussion
of
names (I'm seriously behind in my mail), but
after all
the deserved complaints about Bart and
Kathy continuing
to mispronounce the names of Kochetkova and others,
it was
ironic that when we could hear the Russian
PA announcing Shannon Miller,
the "ll" was pronounced
as it would be in French or Spanish (like a gutteral
consonant
"y"). Given the consonant
collection that
Russian has, I'm sure that Jennie Thompson and
Marianna
Webster were tough on the announcers, too.
Soni Meduna should have been a
relative piece of cake.
Did Fabrichnova,
especially on beam, remind anyone else
of Boginskaya?
Even little things, like how she pointed
her
toes, and how she moved out to the end of beam and
prepared
herself for her tumbling pass. I
didn't notice
this resemblance last year--has she
grown substantially?
Is there a coach in common?
>>Kathy
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 94 23:09:45 BST
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: Goodwill Games
(Rhythmic)
Goodwill Games Rhythmic Gymnastics:
There are only
eight competitors and it resulted in quite
an
uneventful event I feel. Amina Zaripova
the clear favourite
swept
the field, though I'm surprised that Serebrianskaya
didn't
make a stronger challenge for any of the
titles.
Zaripova is sooo
supple that I still can't believe despite watching
her
for a couple of years. Gontar the young star is
shining brighter
bit by bit. Caroline Hunt of the
US did well too I feel, but being
no expert in
this field, I have not a good idea of how they come up
with
those marks. I was beginning to like Olga Vershinina
(first
time I saw her) when she dropped her clubs
at least four times in
her All-Around routine. Skorupinska is very Polish looking. And
the German commentator is confusing Albena
Angova of Bulgaria with
Olga Gontar
(Not just the commentator but the whole German
production
team was showing Angova's
routine during the later highlights program
and
said that's the bronze medallist Olga Gontar.) Cardenoso the
Spainaird is getting better and finished a good fourth
place.
They didn't show the event finals and I don't know the results
but
Susan's already posted them. Here are the All-Around final results
again just for completeness:
1. Amina
Zaripova
(RUS) 39.000
2. Ekaterina Serebrianskaya
(UKR)
38.400
3. Olga Gontar
(BLR)
38.375
4. Amaya Cardenoso
(ESP)
37.500
5. Katazyna Skorupinska (POL) 37.350
6. Albena Angova
(BUL)
37.125
7. Caroline Hunt
(USA) 36.750
8.
Olga Vershinina
(RUS)
35.250
Sherwin
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 03 Aug 94 05:47:14 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Goodwill RSG EF
Results
>From the AP (Rachele said she
didn't have 'em so here they are)...
Individual Apparati
Ball
1. Amina
Zaripova, Russia, 9.800.
2. Olga Gontar,
Belarus, 9.725.
3. Yekat Serebryanskaya, Ukraine,
9.625.
4. Katarzyn Skorupinska, Poland,
9.400.
5. Caroline Hunt,
United States, 9.325.
6.
Olga Vershinina, Russia, 9.025.
7. Amaya Cardenoso,
Spain, 8.700.
8. Albena Angova, Bulgaria,
8.450.
Ribbon
1. Serebryanskaya,
9.775
2. Gontar, 9.650
3. Zaripova,
9.450
(tie) Skorupinska, 9.450
5. Cardenoso,
9.425
6. Angova, 9.375
7. Hunt, 9.250
8. Vershinina,
8.650
Hoop
1. Zaripova, 9.775.
2. Gontar,
9.750.
3. Serebryanskaya, 9.725.
4. Skorupinska,
9.400.
(tie) Cardenoso, 9.400.
6. Angova, 9.250.
7. Hunt, 9.200.
8. Vershinina,
9.000.
Clubs
1. Zaripova, 9.750
(tie). Serebryanskaya, 9.750
3. Gontar,
9.700
4. Cardenoso, 9.425
5. Skorupinska,
9.400
6. Angova, 9.375
7. Hunt, 9.225
8. Vershinina,
9.050
Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 3 Aug 94 0:24:55 18000
From: <***@freenet.scri.fsu.edu>
Subject:
GWG,Men's team
I've
got some free time tonight,so
I thought I thought I'd comment on
today's
competition.
First of all,cheers
to TBS for having FANTASTIC coverage.Now if only
the other networks could follow suit.If
a meet is taped(like this one)
they(the other
networks) need to show the routine and maybe one replay
and
move on to the next gymnast(like TBS did).I'd say this was the
best coverage I've seen since '89 worlds on ESPN.
Secondly,I was suprised
by Blaine and Drew who did a great job at
their
first international meet.On the other hand Chainey and
Scott(*ESPECIALLY*
Scott) S-U-C-K-E-D.I don't understand what the hell
their
problem is.Does anyone out there know or have any
ideas? Can
they
EVER hit all their their routines?And
this is just the first
day!!!!!!!Yah,they recieved
the Bronze medal but had this been Dortmond
(and had the other
teams sent their best)they would have finished
WAAAYYYY back.I mean they were barely able to
hold off the other b-teams for!And
they were in the final round where
the scores are higher!In Dortmond they'll be in
the first round during
compulsories so they might
not even make the final six.They need to
find out what their problem is,solve
it,and spend a lot more time in
the gym.We have the facilities and
coaches,so I think maybe the
problem
is within the gymnasts themselves or maybe there is a struggle
between the coaches.I honestly
don't know,but if things don't change
the US men's team is never going to challenge the top
teams.
Are all the P-bar routines looking alike or is it just me.healy.double
back or double
front.double pike dismount.Wasn't
it *wise* for the new
code not to award originality.I hope they bring it back after '96.I
think it's wonderful that Chorkina
basically ignores the code and
throws some of the
coolest tricks in the code.
I WAS a little disappointed that they
didn't mention who made AA.I
guess we'll just have
to wait till tomorrow.I hope Blaine and Drew
made it.
Billy
--
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 03 Aug 94 05:27:38 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Indian
Gymnastics (was Re: names)
Hey they had a full men's team (3 gymnasts
at that meet) at '93 Worlds. One
of their guys
attempted a handspring double front on vault and hey he was
closer then Korby.
Checking
my handy dandy 50 pence "Results Book" the Indian guys finished
...
121st overall in prelims - Debnath
Ratan, 40.225 ... Valut
gave him his
highest score of 7.975 and a low of
5.925 on PH
118th - Vikas Sabharwal 41.975 ... High of 7.9 on vault and a low of
6.025
on HB
116th - Rajesh Kumar 42.475 ... His hand
double attempt gave him his highest
score of 8.025
and his lowest was a 5.45 on PH
Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 14:32:34 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Kochetcova discredited unfairly
I noticed
something on the *P BB that really did disturb me. I see a few
people
on there discrediting Dina K.'s victory in the AA by saying she only
won it because she was in Russia etc. This is completely untrue and
really
unfortunate to see. When are people going to see that
Shannon Miller is not
the only excellent gymnast
out there? I can see that it's hard
to see
someone else win besides SHannon because she's been smokin
for two years but,
why can't people just accept a
loss? It really wasn't a loss at
all anyway.
After all Shannon
has gone through w/ a growth spurt, a developing body and
injuries, she should be happy that she can still compete so
well. I'm really
happy to be able to discuss gymnastics with well informed
people like you all
who will not judge a gymnast
by their country but, there performances.
Dina
Kotchetkova deserved the AA title and
she will be a contender throughout the
next two
years. I can't wait to see more of
her.---Brian
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 14:11:53 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Marianna
Webster
I think Marianna did so well in EF. Her score on beam was upped to a
9.725,
which gave her the bronze medal. I found out during the floor exercise
while
watching TBS. Kathy and Bart brought it up. Also, while being interviewed,
Marianna
had a medal around her neck.
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 94 23:24:00 EDT
From: <***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>
Subject:
Men's team
Go Grigory! :) Awesome vault - I'd love to see
him win this AA title. So
where are the rest of
the Ukrainian men? Can Korobchinsky, Sharipov, Marinich,
Shamenko ALL be injured? And why
isn't Ivankov competing? Has anyone found that
out yet? I was sort of hoping Bart and Kathy might explain
the no-shows (I
guess I was suffering from
temporary insanity). The Russians are great, despite
their
uncharacteristic errors. Shabayev is my favorite. But
back to the topic
of temporary insanity - how
could Arkaev, such an experienced coach, and
Voropayev, such an experienced competitor, both fail to
notice that he was not
wearing the right shorts on
floor?! I mean, Arkaev's been coaching FOREVER!
With
all his accumulated errors, did Voropayev (listen to
the Russian
announcer, not to Bart - that's all
I'll say) even make AA? I know Misyutin was
the top qualifier and Shabayev the
top Russian, but what are the rest of the
standings?
Anyone know?
Beth
------------------------------
Date:
Wed, 03 Aug 94 05:27:05 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Men's Team &
RSG Rundown as Well as AA Predictions
First off on a purely hormonal
note let me say the Russian boy's are *Yummy*
with
a capital "Y-U-M" Okay on with the show ("this is it .. da da da"
any
Looney Tunes fans out there getting this?).
The Russians had
what could quite possibly be the worst meet of their lives
and the nearly 4 point score gap between them and Belarus
still didn't really
accurately reflect the actual
gap in talent.
Nemov is a little god with
big fuzzy hair. Toe point to die for. Leg form
that
makes Bogie look like Dawes (yes Susan is being catty again ... get over
it) and a double pike that that Chinese diving girl would
envy if she'd seen
it. P-bars are amazing ... the
Russian's overall really excel here (and
everywhere
else of course but here especially). Maybe Khorkina
can help him
with that vault. On high bar that kid
can do a lay out full twisting Tkatchev
that would blow your mind. Unfortunately, he then falls on
the plain laid out
one and then gets knocked out
of the AA in favor of Voropaev who pretty much
self
destructed anyway ... but then again Susan (why do I keep referring to
myself in the third person tonight?) is
still bitter about '93 which he
probably doesn't
even remember. He's possibly my
favorite gymnast competing
now (well after Karbonenko who's injured & Kharkov who's in Germany
pouting
and maybe Igor who's just a sentimental
favorite but Nemov is the prettiest
... got that? ... there *will* be a quiz later)
Voropaev
was beautiful but a lot more Alexei like then that weird consistent
guy we saw in the AA at Brisbane. This is the boy who
crashed and burned on
*compo* vault in both '91
and '92. Usually Sovs don't get the chance to
make
errors twice. He looked as if someone had run
over his dog ... this was not a
happy camper ...
and who can blame him with a night like this? His rings
were
a stunner (so still and controlled ... to bad we couldn't see the ROM
boy Burinca here). His HB was
gutsy but really a 9.35 with a fall? I wonder
what
Evgeny said when he got his 9.2 something for an
essentially hit set
(slight hitch out of his
Kovacs).
Speaking of the Kovacs. It's the Layout Pak Salto of Russian
men's high bar.
Not that I'm complaining mind you ... they do it quite
well. Though I
really
wanna' see Alexei go for the Kovacs -hop full-Kovacs that I heard he was
training.
Well gotta' mention Rudnitsky on
this one. His Kovacs in Phoenix
(the tri-meet) was
really up there but it was even better here. Even higher
then
Ivankov's ... who practically has to file a flight
plan before mounting.
To compare it to Trent Dimas's barely adequate move
was nothing short of
cruel and unusual punishment.
I mean Trent did the move okay but he was too
worried
about catching it to worry about the finer things. Note to Bart:
There was no '90 Jr. Europeans (not AA or EF anyway ... was there
a team?) so
Rudnitsky was 'fer
sure not the champ there ... unless Bart is holding
imaginary
meets in his mind again.
Shabaev. What can I
say? He's Nemov but cuter and a smidge less extended
(due
mostly to the fact that he's a good 4 inches
shorter then the "giant" Nemov).
Nance
and I found a shot of him as a skinny little nobody Sov
in the '89
Champions All. Trying to grow a mustache (too many reruns of
"Miami Vice" for
him ... though I must say it works) and look
"cool." How cute! Well at least
he
finally manages stubble unlike Scherbo who's been
working on that walrus
look for at least 5 years
with little success.
Vassilenko = double
front. Wowsers! I thought that Kharkov's '88 was the
best
I'd seen but this blew him
away (sorry Sergei ... I still love you though
... and
that '88 FX as a whole is still the best I've ever seen). He looked
like it could just have easily been a triple front. A triple front? Ponder
the
lifespan of a knee on someone trying that one. Ouch! Put it on the
"moves
I'd like to see list" along with a full twisting Yurchenko loop on BB and a
Kovacs on unevens. Interesting note: The Japanese who can't say
"L's"
(RacheLe'd love them ;-) call him
"Vasserenko" which is much more fun to
say. All together now ... VASSERENKO.
To
sum the Russkie's up I think Adriana put it best when
she said "I could
just
stare at the Russians' handstands on PB for hours." Ditto. Actually I
could
just stare at the Russian boys for
hours period (I may be the only
women in the world
who's description of the "perfect guy" includes toe point)
... but I bet you
already guessed that eh? Seriously
though, that's the
diff ... technique, technique,
technique. Sure they did some huge skills but
more
then that it's the *way* they did them. I mean Nemov's
best skill, IMHO,
is his double pike which is like
what a "C" maybe ?
It was great to see Grigori
back and looking good (well the hair was still
bad
but hey he's Sov - okay "was" Sov - and it's a law. In fact a law that
Shabaev is in violation of now that I think of it. Does he think he's
too
cool for bad hair? How un-Russian of him.).
His double front is grand as
ever. Slightly less
toe point but no-one does it that well anyway so
I'll
cute the "old" guy some slack.
Besides he walked around half naked a lot
(removing
that eyesore of a leo of all the UKR leo's why would he choose that
one?)
which garners him bonus in my book. ;-)
Ukraine
has a full men's team easy: Korobchinskii (current
Euro silver
medalist ... indulge me I just get a
kick out of calling Igor an AA
medalist
again), Marinich
(back from the dead ... or Woodward which is kinda'
the same
thing), Ermakov
(who's haircut Voropaev stole for some odd reason. Oh
I know
Alexei was in violation of that "bad hair law" I
mentioned. Remember he used
to look like kind of a
"preppie Russian" which just isn't natural), Shemenko
<sp?> (who I've never seen but
has done okay in a couple of fairly big
meets).
Scott.
Two out and out falls (and one on a half turn on PB for god's sake!)
and a HB Geinger that wasn't even
close. Two major stumbles. His FX (every
pass) and
that huge PH bumble (is that a word?). All in all an average meet
for Scott the wonder boy. "Lord of the Rings" my
ass. Feel free to whine at
me about these comments
... I don't bite ... well only when there's a full
moon
and I've been dieting and then I only nibble and feel guilty about it in
the morning ;-)
Drew did a lot better then I would
have thought. His Gaylord 2 into Stalder
(or was it Endo?) was cool if not
perfect. I won't even go into the grace and
beauty
that is Blaine Wilson (just not the same without Kip by his side).
Onto a happier (slightly) subject, the Belarussian's.
Shostak really
surprised
me. Pleasantly so that is. Great rings ... esp. for a
guy with arms
the size of eyelashes. They skipped
his FX but he's ultra flexible a la
Balabonov (great Y). He
broke at the Aussie Nikon Int'l thingie along
with
Yulia Yurkina (now
there's a couple that would produce some sturdy kids ...
of
course a Yurkina and Belanovsky - better known as "No Butt" - would be
even
better. Their
children would just be born and then disintegrate. A
unique new form of child care that could really catch on.).
His pommels, p's,
and HB were all quite decent. Go
figure.
Rudnitsky looked better then before
but both he and Pavlovsky are pretty
forgettable.
Kan's
alive!!! Kan's alive!!!! The Chinese (in looks and
consistency factors)
Soviet boy has now bettered his own record and hit 2
meets in his life (watch
out Scott he's gaining on
you). Andrei's cool even if he can't really hit or
do
the really big stuff. He's an original all right. Was that huge thing
that he mounted FX with a pike Arabian double front. Neat-o
Keen to the max
babe (I can't believe I said
that). You also gotta'
love this irony ... He's
a Mongolian horde throw
back named "Kan" (ie:
Khan) who was born in White
Russia
(ie: Belarus). Ha! ... well
I found it funny anyway. BTW, those BLR
leos are *ugly*.
Rhythmic ... well all five
minutes of it we saw was nice. Zaripova is
simply
not human. Nancy suggests thinking of them
as cartoon characters to alleviate
your fear and
revulsion. Her start and end poses alone are worth a look see
even if you're not an RSG fan. Her ball routine is the living end
(sorry
Skaldina ... wherever you are). That black thing she wore for hoop
finals ...
oh la la. Her
leaps. I could gush forever but I won't (you can stop
thanking
god now). She and Serebrianskaya
are my favs. That Polish girl spins better
then most ballerinas and she actually has a butt. Overall
for RSG gals they
all looked pretty healthy. Maybe
this was the month they get to eat. Also,
did you
get a load of that venue? Geez it had a full crowd (in Russia!) and a
stunning backdrop (columns and all) for what is an
esthetically driven
sport/art. It was a perfect theater for their
art.
Lastly, is it just me or are those guys
that host the whole Goodwill thing
giving more
intelligent gymnastics commentary then Bart and Kathy?
So did Vorop make the AA cut or not? Esp. after that 2 tenths
"wrong shorts"
deduction. Yeah Steve and
Bart that home town advantage has really helped the
Russians
out of many jams. I'd personally like to see Nemov,
Shabaev, and
Voropaev [Aside to Rachele:
that's the name that rolls of the tongue for me
... say
it a couple times rolling the "R" and see if you don't agree ...
very
exotic ... very Russian ... besides Alexei is
my favorite name]. Dmitri is
nice but not a real
exciting all arounder.
My AA picks are as
follows ... Shabaev 'cause the guys damn consistent
when
it counts. If Voropaev
makes it he could be just angry enough about his
miserable day to take the cake here. Grisha will
also challenge but probably
make some error that
loses it for him. Nemov will most likely get a
bronze
behind some of these guys. I betcha' that Scott's got a large bit of the
falling out of his system and pulls out a good finish here.
He tends to do so
in AA's. Now when I'm wrong you
can all make fun of me and call me stupid.
:-)
As Always (read:
"Bitchy and lengthy"),
Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 11:37:34 +0800
From: ***@Eng.Sun.COM
Subject:
names
As Robyn's post about the Russian announcer's pronunciation of
"Miller"
suggested, it's actually next
to impossible to get a foreign name correct.
The vocabulary is different
and the same sounds don't exist.
Anyone that
has taken a foreign language
must be aware of this. Because of
this, you
could spend four years preparing to
pronounce those Russian and Chinese
names exactly
the way a native would say them, only to mispronunce
them
anyway, relative to the way your audience
would say them. Someone from
Japan
would not pronounce "Miller" the way Shannon would say it. (Actually,
nobody
outside of Oklahoma would pronouce it the way she
would!)
And if they spelled "Miller" out in katakana (the
alphabet used to spell
words of foreign origin),
indeed its spelling would agree with the way the
Japanese speaker says
it.
-George
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 13:29:33 -0700 (PDT)
From: ***@netcom.com Subject:
names
> >Anyway, Im getting off trach here, but it takes little time to learn
> >pronounciations of names. I still have trouble with southeast asian names. I
> >still
cant for the life of my pronounce the name Huyn
yet. I only learned a
> >week agpo to pronounce Nguyen
correctly (pronounced 'wen')
>
> Hmm, a friend of mine with that
name said (approximately) NOO-ee-en. The
> one
I can't figure out is Ng (I have heard "eng"
but I don't think that's
> really
right...)
Ng is "eng" only by itself, and even that I think is only in chinese.
S E Asia, its a whole
new set of rules with just enough French tossed in to
make
it interesting.
Actually
I suspect that Rachele's pronunviation
of Nguyen is better than mine.
I vote for "noo-een"
too.
But I am making great improvements in Indian names now.
You
just have to say them slowly until you get the speed up.
Hmmmm..... How
come we never hear of Indian gymnasts ?
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 13:34:52 -0700 (PDT)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject:
names
{...}
>
> Actually, in Sunday's competition, I
heard the Russian announcer
> mispronouncing
"Miller" as MEE-yer, so it's not only the
American
> announcers who do it.
>
>
--Robyn
They are having a rough time because spanish is becoming part of the USA.
Double l in spannish is pronounced as a y.
The russians are having a heck of a time figuring out
when the j is a j
and when its an h (as in San
Jose')
I think we yanks are the worst about not bothering to get names
right.
Just last week "Hey man, Im moving
down to 'Josey'" (meaning San Jose)
I was embarassed to over hear such a conversation.
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 13:53:00 -0700 (PDT)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject:
names
{...}
>
> I mean I have even known
> some sports personalities change their names because
>
they know the
> TV people will never get it
right.
Being in the "biz" I can say sadly you are
right.
> The pronounciation or the
spelling of the name should be
> sorted out,
its a common decency surely. How come there isnt
>
some form of group which represents the gymnasts
themselves
> for just this kind of thing, call
it a union if you like
> but most sports have
something like this.
Unionize the gymnasts ?!? Are you outta your mind
?!?
Next thing they will want is pizza, and after that maybe
sensible
diets and hours. ACK !!! THPPPBBLLTT !
Something like that could start getting on
Bela & Nunno's cases whjen they
abuse their girls
! How you expect gymn to survive in this country if we
allow the kids to stand up to authority ?
I mean abuse
of young girls is what keeps gymn running
!
Tongue planted FIRMLY in cheek !
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 94 22:40:16 BST
From: ***@ic.ac.uk
Subject: names
Regarding
pronounciation of names, the BBC here in UK are very good
at them. They do
research on how to pronounce them before they say
it.
The latest of which is Nadia Hatagan,
they especially say it as
'Hertzergan'
because they said that is how it should be pronounced.
(I'm no expert of
course, bit I'm taking their words for it) I just
love
the BBC commentary, they get you excited and their infos
are
correct and they don't over-criticise the gymnasts. My favourite
line from a BBC commentary is probably during the 92
Olympics,
during Milosovici's
floor exercise in the floor final. Just before
her
incredible second tumbling pass, Mitch Fenner our
commentator
said, 'If you think the first tumble
was magic, watch this.' (Her
first tumble was
full-in back-out punch front) Then after Milo's
second
complex tumble, Mitch yelled 'Unbelievable!'. That got me
real excited.
BTW, as to how to say 'Ng', It's similar to saying 'Hmmm' but with
your mouth open. Try it!
Sherwin
(No problem saying my surname, I hope!)
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 94 18:01:25 EDT
From: <***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>
Subject:
names
Texx could very well be right that the Russians took the
"ll" in "Miller"
to be pronounced "y," as in Spanish. But I think
the announcer probably did
have an "l"
in there, only it would be hard for American ears to hear it.
Russian has
2 "l" sounds, one "hard," one "soft." When I
heard the announcer, I
thought she was using the
Russian soft "l." I think the problem actually lay
with the "i," since,
strange as this may seem, the Russian language does not
have
that sound (the English soft i). So even though
"Miller" is an incredibly
easy name for
English-speakers to pronounce, a Russian would have to practice a
LOT to
get it right. On the whole, I thought the Russian announcer did quite
well with the American names, considering they were full of
sounds that don't
exist at all in Russian (the
"a" in "Shannon," the "j" in "Jennie,"
the "o" in
"Soni,"
the "w" in "Webster," and the aforementioned "i" in Miller). Russian
only
has "pure" vowel sounds, with the exception of "eh" - they
can do that.
But things like "u" as in "but,"
"a" as in "cat," and other "flat" sounds
simply do not exist in Russian. So I wouldn't fault the
announcer too much for
getting those sounds wrong.
Similarly, I don't fault any American commentator
for
getting "kh," "shch"
and "y" (when it's in the middle of a name, like
"Lysenko,"
not when it's at the end - then it's easy: "ee"),
because those
sounds do not exist in English. The
"y" is by far the hardest - it's a strange
sort
of sound made at the back of your throat and English has NO equivalent to
it. So most people end up saying "Lee-sen-ko" or "Lie-sen-ko," neither of
which
is correct, but I can't really criticize
English-speakers for not being able to
pronounce a
sound that doesn't exist in English. When I criticized Bart and
Kathy for
mispronouncing "Kochetkova," it was because
that name is not hard for
English-speakers to pronounce.
All they had to do was shift the stress and they
had
it right. But I was much easier with them on "Khorkina,"
since "Kh" doesn't
exist
in English, so they'd have to practice a lot to get it right.
Beth
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 18:47:02 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: names
Y'all
have to remember that Shannon Miller with a New York announcer will be
"Milla."
In Alabama she'd be Shannnnneeen.
In RusskieLand
there are all kinds of accents. How crazy are we going to get
with all of this.
Scherbow
---Scherba
When will the glottal stop!
David
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 94 19:48:26 EDT
From: <***@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu>
Subject:
NY Times on eating disorders
Did anyone else see
yesterday's (Aug. 1) article in the NY Times on eating
disorders?
It was very interesting, and accompanied by an Aug. 1993 photo of
Christy and her fiance. I NEVER
would have recognized Christy if the caption
hadn't
said it was her. She was smiling and looked happy, but was very
emaciated. It was a scary, and very sad, sight... The
article raised some
interesting questions and
points. (Btw, it's by Neil Amdur - I don't want to
violate any copyright rules here!) First, in a
section headed "Biochemicals or
Behavior?"
it says that researchers haven't yet figured out "what comes first
in the process - the biochemical imbalance in the brain that
causes athletes to
lose weight or behavioral
components." A Dr. Julia Taub later comments
that
once female athletes get anorexia "the
disease controls them. It takes over."
But what I found extremely
interesting is some studies that were done comparing
how
the male and female bodies respond to exercise. One study followed "a
group
of male and female novices training for
their first marathon. Over a period of
80 weeks, the men showed a loss of
body weight and fat, while the women had no
change."
Two other studies were mentioned that yielded the same results: the
men lost body weight and % of fat mass, and the women
didn't. Dr. Taub
concludes
"If exercise or physical activity on its own, as it does with males,
does not result in desirable weight loss for women, they
must resort to
restrictive dieting. They take it
too far and the result is anorexia." I had
never
known about this difference between males and females when it comes to
exercise and weight loss, but it sure does a lot to explain
why most anorexics
are female.
On the same page of
the Times there is an article covering W AA, and it
says
that Steve Nunno said he might have Shannon skip the
1995 Worlds. Does
anyone know if this was a typo
by the Times? I thought Steve had been talking
about
not sending Shannon to *Dortmund*, not Sabae. Anyway,
it certainly seems
a bit early to be making
decisions about Sabae!
Beth
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 19:21:59 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
PR, USA Nationals
PR would mean, of course, Press Release. (And yes, Susan, I'm really
talking about a Press Release this time, but thanks for
checking.
grin)
July 22, 1994
Luan
Peszek, Director of Public Relations
Ramonna Robinson, Manager of Public Relations
Two-Time
World Champion Miller Leads Roster for
1994 Coca-Cola National Gymnastics
Championships
Shannon Miller (Edmond, Okla.), the only two-time
American World
Gymnastics Champion in history, is set to defend her
national title at
the 1994 Coca-Cola National
Gymnastics Championships, August 24-27, in
Nashville,
Tennessee's Municipal Auditorium.
Miller will be challenged by
1992 Olympians Dominique Dawes (Silver
Spring, Md.) and
Kerri Strug (Tucson, Ariz.). Other members of
the
1994 World ChampionshipsTeam expected to
compete include Larissa
Fontaine (Deerfield, Ill.) and Amanda Borden
(Cincinnati, Ohio). 1993
Junior National Champion Jennie Thompson (training
in Oklahoma City,
Okla.) is moving to the senior
division and should challenge for one
of the top
positions.
Three-time National Champion and 1992 Olympian John
Roethlisberger
(Afton, Minn.) will lead the men's
roster. By winning another national
title, Roethlisbergerwill become the first gymnast since Mako Sakamoto
(1963-1966) to
win four national all-around titles. Roethlisberger
will
be challenged by 1992 Olympians Scott Keswick (UCLA), Chris
Waller
(Albuquerque, N.M.), and Jair Lynch (Stanford). 1992
Olympic
Gold Medalist Trent Dimas (Albuquerque, N.M.) is also expected to
make
a come back and challenge for a spot on the
National team. Mihai Bagiu
and Chainey Umphrey,
both 1994 World Championships Team Members from
Albuquerque, N.M,are also top contenders.
Junior
National Champions Katie Teft from Grand Rapids,
Mich., and
Doni Thompson from Colorado Springs,
Colo., are set to compete as
well.
These two athletes tied for first all-around at the 1994
American
Classic in the Junior Division. Thompson captured the gold
all-around medal at the U.S. Olympic Festival-'94, along
with gold
medals on beam and bars and silver
medals on floor and in the team
competition.
The
top 20 women and 14 men will earn spots on the Senior National
Team, while
four men will qualify to the Senior Elite Development
Team. An additional
12 women and seven men will make the Junior
National
Team.
The top 16 women from this competition will qualify to the
NationsBank
World Gymnastics Team Trials to be held October 15-16 in
Richmond, Va.
The top seven men will make up
the 1994 World Championships Team,
which will
travel to Dortmund, Germany, Nov. 11-20, for the Team World
Gymnastics
Championships.
The Coca-Cola National Gymnastics Championships are
scheduled to air
on NBC August 27 and 28.
The
competition schedule is as follows:
Wednesday, August 24
Jr. Women's Compulsories
10:00 a.m. $5 all
levels
Jr. & Sr. Men's Compulsories
2:00 p.m. $5 all
levels
Sr. Women's Compulsories
7:00 p.m.
$15/$8/$5
Thursday, August 25
Jr. Women's
Optionals
2:00 p.m. $5 all
levels
Jr. & Sr. Men's Optionals
7:00 p.m.
$15/$8/$5
Friday, August 26
Sr. Women's Optionals
7:00 p.m.
$20/$15/$10
Saturday, August 27
Sr. Men's
Individual Event Finals 1:00 p.m.
$20/$15/$10
Sr. Women's Individual Event
Finals 6:00 p.m. $20/$15/$10
Tickets
are on sale at all Ticket Pro locations including Municipal
Auditorium Box
Office, Hickory Hollow Mall Customer Service Center and
Sheplers
Western Wear in Rivergate. Reserve tickets (with or
without a
credit card) at 291-5000 or (outside
Nashville) at 800/834-5678. Visit
a participating
Kroger store Coca-Cola gymnastics display for $3
discount
coupons. For group discounts call 615/832-0250.
---------
Btw,
I will be at USA Nationals this year, and yes I'll have Geneve
(my portable) with me, and she and I will be busy dashing off
reports
to keep you all up to date (although it
will be on TV [not all of it,
of course]... and I
won't be there for compulsories...)
I'm going to try to get in some
athlete/coach interviews while I'm
there. If there's anyone in particular that you
want to know more
about, let me know and, time and
opportunity permitting, I'll get in
an
interview.
Rachele
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 21:25:21 -0500 (CDT)
From: <***@owlnet.rice.edu>
Subject:
Retton's 10th anniversary
The AP has written
this incredibly long story about Retton's gold
in
1984 since tomorrow (August 3rd) marks the 10 year
anniversary. It's
basically a rehash of the book she wrote with Karolyi. The
article
makes this big todo
about how Retton's arthroscopic surgery was a
huge
secret before the Games (hunh?)
and about how she wouldn't talk about
it publicly
until now (umm... yeah...).
Anyways. I'm not going to post it to Gymn because we've had *so*much*
traffic
lately, and this sucker is 558 lines long, and I'm all
tuckered
out from dissecting the real news (read: GG). However, if
you
happen to be a big Retton fan, and just can't get
enough of that
"1,000 watt smile" (I'll allow myself one direct
quote), then feel
free to email me and I'll send
you the article.
Rachele
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 12:44:30 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: RSG Results from
Goodwill
From the AP
...
All-Around
1. Amina
Zaripova, Russia, 39.000 points.
2. Yekat
Serebryanskaya, Ukraine, 38.400.
3. Olga Gontar,
Belarus, 38.375.
4.
Amaya Cardenoso, Spain, 37.500.
5. Katarzyn
Skorupinska, Poland, 37.350.
6. Albena
Angova, Bulgaria, 37.125.
7. Caroline Hunt, United States,
36.750.
8. Olga Vershinina, Russia, 35.250.
All-Around Individual Apparati
Hoop--1, Zaripova, 9.750. 2, Serebryanskaya, 9.600. 3, Gontar, 9.500. 4,
Cardenoso, 9.400. 5, Angova, 9.400. 6, Skorupinska, 9.300. 7, Hunt,
9.050. 8,
Vershinina, 8.950.
Ball--1, Zaripova, 9.700.
2, Gontar, 9.600. 3, Serebryanskaya, 9.600. 4,
Cardenoso,
9.350. 5, Skorupinska,
9.350. 6, Angova, 9.300.
7, Hunt, 9.250. 8,
Vershinina, 9.000.
Ribbon--1, Zaripova, 9.750.
2, Gontar, 9.700. 3, Serebryanskaya, 9.550. 4,
Cardenoso,
9.400. 5, Skorupinska,
9.400. 6, Angova, 9.300.
7, Hunt, 9.200. 8,
Vershinina, 8.800.
Clubs--1, Zaripova, 9.800.
2, Serebryanskaya, 9.650. 3, Gontar, 9.575. 4,
Cardenoso,
9.350. 5, Skorupinska,
9.300. 6, Hunt, 9.250. 7, Angova,
9.125. 8,
Vershinina, 8.500.
Susan
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 13:38:45 +1000
From: <***@pharm.med.upenn.edu>
Subject:
Senior Men - National Qualifyer scores
Okay
- this is from a fax, so forgive me if I get some of the club guy's
names wrong. I
work with NCAA - just remember that before you start
berateing.
These are the weighted scores.
This list does not include the
1993-94 Senior
National Team Members. The
top 22 qualify into the 1994
Coca-Cola National
Championships.
People petitioning - Mike Williams, Chris
Waller, Tom Meadows ( interesting
since he did go to a qualifier and got 41st.), Dennis
Harrison
I notice that Trent Dimas is not on this list - he is
injured, taking
adavantage
of winter nationals (like Mike Racanelli) or not
really going to
do a come back?
---------------------------------
NAME
REGION
CLUB
ADJUSTED SCORE
1 Bryan
Casey Mid West U of
Ok
108.60
2 Jeremy Kellen
Mid West U of
OK
108.32
3 John Maoneady
Mid West
OTC
107.88
4 Jeff LaVallee
East
Daggett's 107.40
5 Kyle Asano
(sp?)Mid West
OTC
106.94
6 J.D. Refvo (sp?)Mid
West
OTC
106.88
7 Brent
Klaus East
International
106.50
8 Josh
Stein
West
Stanford
106.38
9 Mike Masucci
East Penn
State
106.18
10 Jarrod
Hanks Mid West U of
OK
106.16
11 Mike Dennuci
West
UCLA
104.98
12 Spencer Slaton West
UCLA
104.88 or .86
13 Jason Christie Mid Esat U.
of Neb
104.82
14 John
Thornton Mid East
Hawkeye gym
104.62
15 Calvin
Booker East
Daggett's
104.26
16 Michael
Moran East
Daggett's
103.88
17 Lou Daillo Mid West
OTC
103.84
18 Todd Brumley
East
Knoxville gym
103.76
19 Larry Johns Mid West U of
OK
103.40
20 Mark Booth West
Stanford
103.04
21 Rick Kieller(sp?) Mid East U of Neb
102.48
22 Nat Goodale East
Ohio State
102.38
------------------------------------------------------------------
23 John Vogt Mid
East
Hawkeye gym
101.74
24 Garry Denk Mid East Northbrook gym 101.40
25 Aaron Coller
Mid East
Hawkeye gym
100.72
26 Dave Frank East
Temple U
100.22
27 Greg Umphery
West
UCLA
100.05 (.03)
28 Brian Ottenhoff Mid East U. of
Minn 99.70
29
Keith Wiley
West
Stanford U. 98.90
30 Martin
Larsen West
98.25
31 Chris Young Mid East
Carolina Twisters 97.54
32 Don Brown Mid
East Browns Metro 97.50
33 Mark Oliver South
U of Wash 97.14
34 George Hery
West
96.26
35 Chase Penny Mid East U of
Ill/Chic 95.90
36 Kirk
Johnson West
95.44
37 Mark Mehringer East
Daggett's 95.40
38 Doug Seibet (sp)Mid East
Northbrook gym 92.96
39 Chad Duncan South
HGC
89.70 (could be 88.70)
40 Richard
Grace Mid East U of
Neb
84.10
41 Tom Meadows Mid West U of
OK
76.70
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 17:11:04 +1000
From: <***@pharm.med.upenn.edu>
Subject:
Senior Men - National Qualifyer scores
>>10 Jarrod
Hanks Mid West U of
OK
106.16<
>
>If you happen to have any recent info on him
I'd be interested to hear it.
> Haven't heard anything since he blew out
his shoulder (was that it or was it
>a knee or
ankle) last year on p's.
>
I will check on his status tonight
and post what I find out. But from
the
score I would say he has made a full recovery
from his injuries - I think
you are right about it
being the shoulder, but then there are lots of
injuries
out there, so it could be a knee.
>Also do all these guys (top 22)
*plus* last years team get to go to
>nationals? I noticed Keith Wiley finished below the
cut off ... bummer nice
>guy and some *super*
tumbling when he hits it. Isn't
Richard Grace Canadian?
Shame about Dave Frank too, his Rings scores were
the best - in compos. he
came
off the horse 3 times and 2 times in opt.
I know he is planning to
revise the opt. set for winter nationals. He is one of the guys with great
form.
Richard
Grace is not Canadian - unless he is pulling dual citizenship.
>Is
Waller injured or just not up to a qualifier.
I don't think he is
injured, but I can nose around on that one tonight
also. I plan on making a few phone calls, so
he'll be included.
your welcome,
Mayland
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 21:28:05 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Shannon
>What
would Shannon's absence do to NBC's coverage? Would it >be enough for
them to drop it?
NBC will air the USA Nationals
regardless of who attends. As you all know
this
will be a particularly interesting meet with all kinds of emerging
stars.
We will air the Women's All-Around on
Saturday from 8-9 eastern time (only 1
hour, but . . . . .) Hopefully we'll get some Men's highlites in.
Event finals air on Sunday from 7-8
pm. Imagine cramming all that in an
hour!!!
That's
the hand we're dealt. That's what the marketplace dictates. But two
hours in prime time is cool nevertheless.
Can't
wait to hear all the rips from the Gymn maniacs after
we're done. Just
because I'm online with you guys
doesn't mean you can't go wild about the NBC
Coverage if it's not up to
snuff.
We all know Susan and Mara will unload the bombs!!!!!
Regards,
David
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 14:03:57 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Wants to go Back
Hello, its Jessica
again. I am 12, and quit level 9 18
months ago,
because my coach pushed to hard, and
didn't care about the gymnasts at all,
just
winning. Now I miss the sport so much, and want to go back, but have
lost so much strength, and may have trouble getting my giant
and
backhandspring-layout
on beam. I also want to visit my
friends. WHAT SHOULD
I DO? Also, I'm now on a competetive
soccer team, which my father somewhat
keeps
pressure on me to stay with it because he didn't like gymnastics as
much as soccer.
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 2 Aug 1994 12:15:18 -0700 (PDT)
From: ***@netcom.com
Subject: Wants to go Back
>
Hello, its Jessica again. I am 12, and quit level 9 18 months
ago,
> because my coach pushed to hard, and
didn't care about the gymnasts at all,
> just
winning. Now I miss the sport so much, and want to go back, but have
> lost so much strength, and may have trouble getting my giant
and
> backhandspring-layout
on beam. I also want to visit my
friends. WHAT SHOULD
> I
DO? Also, I'm now on a competetive soccer team, which my father somewhat
> keeps pressure on me to stay with it because he didn't like
gymnastics as
> much as soccer.
Tell your old man that you love him
very much but gymn is what you truly want to
do and that you are sure that if he loves you, he will go
along with your
wishes. Also tell him that you understasnd his concerns over gymn
as a sport
but you are willing to take your
chances with the injuries. Remond him that
soccer also
has injuries.
Then find a new gymn
coach. Interview THEM. This person is gonna
be working
for YOU. Make it clear that you have expexctations of THEM.
Make sure they
understand why you left
LAST time. Make it clear that you
will NOT permit it
to happen again. Remiond them
that good sportsmanship comes first.
Being 12, its
hard to stand up against a mean nasty adult, but you can do it.
Dont take "NO" for an answer.
Last of all, never forget that old latin
motto "Sockitto'em!"
Go for it !
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 16:22:27 EDT
From: <***@MIT.EDU>
Subject: Wants to
go Back
>Hello, its
Jessica again. I am 12, and quit
level 9 18 months ago,
>because my coach pushed
to hard, and didn't care about the gymnasts at all,
>just
winning. Now I miss the sport so much, and want to go back, but have
>lost so much strength, and may have trouble getting my giant
and
>backhandspring-layout
on beam. I also want to visit my
friends. WHAT SHOULD
>I
DO? Also, I'm now on a competetive soccer team, which my father somewhat
>keeps pressure on me to stay with it because he didn't like
gymnastics as
>much as soccer.
Jessica,
Maybe you could get back into gymn on a
less competitive level (if that would
be of
interest to you) -- work out once or twice a week but not compete.
Lots of gyms offer such a program
-- some call it post-competitive.
Look
around. Also look for "adult" programs which tend to cater to both
beginners
and "retired" gymnasts, helping everyone to practice at their
own level -- you may be a tad young for them, depending on
the group, but
I know of some gyms where the adult programs are where
everyone over 12
who's too good for the basic
recreational program ends up (that is who
aren't
competing).
Try to think about why you want to get back into
gymnastics. Is it the
competition that you love, just doing the sport (if so see
above), the
friends you have made in the gym,
etc.
If you want to get back into competition, you have two choices --
you can
go back to the club you came from where
your friends are but where you
know what the coaching
attitude is like, or you can try to find a new club
as
Texx suggested.
Depending on where you live, though, this may not be
an option for you.
If you just miss your friends,
maybe you could drop by the club and visit
sometime
and arrange to do something else with them (if they have the time).
Good
luck, and let us know what you decide.
I know you put "WHAT SHOULD I
DO?" in your letter, but of
course you have to make that decision for
yourself.
--Robyn
------------------------------
Date:
Tue, 02 Aug 94 21:28:30 EDT
From: ***@aol.com
Subject: Women's AA
Comments
This is from Adriana (Gimnasta) not
me she
sent it to me and asked me to
pass it on if I felt
it was worthwhile. Obviously I do so here it is (exactly
as
she wrote it BTW) ...
Susan
I'm just sending this to you
since I don't know what's been said on Gymn and
I
don't want to be repetitive, so forward at your discretion, if you think
it's worthwhile.
>[score
comparisons]
I know they were having trouble with the computers, so I
don't know whether I
saw the right ones, but I
think some of the scores you compared weren't
accurate
(for ex: BB: 9.887 Miller, 9.85 Kochetkova (not 9.537)).
>Lilyia
actually does the vault correctly (perfectly to be exact ...
completely laidout and impossibly
high)
Podkopayeva's *is* far better
(Miller's scores on that vault are ludicrous),
but
I don't think even she does the 1/2 early enough (none of them do).
It's
so sad to see Chussy vault now. She used to be such a
god on that event
and now is only so so. Poor ChuChu ... she won that
event in both '91 and '92
it's just that no-one
noticed (including the judges).
>Actually, I thought she looked
pretty good; I thought it was the best piked
front half of the meet.
> (it's
a Xiao Rhizu that Malya
does ... not a Kim Gwang Suk as Kathy said
yesterday).
It's a Kim G.S. in women's, a Xiao Ruizhi
in men's.
Thanks so much for sending me all this stuff over the last
few days; I really
appreciate it. Did you write anything about finals? I didn't get anything.
The thing that stands out the most to me
was Miller's vaults. Her second
place
was the most outrageous thing I've seen in a long time. If I'd been
the
STC, I would've been awfully tempted not to count the second vault as a
layout, but as a pike, in which case I'm not sure what would
happen b/c it's
not in the Code (only the Yurchenko versions are; a pike is a 9.8). I assume
she
submits it to the judges before the meet (the layout isn't in the Code
either, b/c she did it for the first time at Worlds but
fell), but if she
submits a layout and does a
pike, which is neither in the Code nor submitted
to
the judges, then she did a "nonexistent" vault and I suppose that
would be
a 0.0. But I'm not a very experienced judge;
this is just my guess. Anyway,
most people are
more lenient than I am, especially with the world champion,
and especially when a 0.0 is involved. <sigh> (If
both were submitted, the
vault would probably
start at 9.8, like the Yurchenko version, and get a
0.3
deduction for calling the wrong vault.) At any rate, I'd go the full 0.3
for
not enough layout position. That's already a 9.7, plus I'd deduct
for ending
the twist too late and for the landing,
which wasn't perfect (and maybe for
insufficient
height, which would be why she had to pike so much, but she also
overrotataed, so I'm not sure she
was really too low; I have to look again),
and
already we're looking at somewhere in the 9.4-9.5 range at most.
Ok,
enough. I'm just so annoyed.
: )
Adriana
------------------------------
End
of gymn Digest
******************************